Review: A History of Private Life, Vol. 2: Revelations of the Medieval World

Edited by Philippe Aries and Georges Duby. Published by Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1988.



Hardcover, 688 pages.
Publisher: Belknap Press, 2003.
ISBN: 0674400011

The History of Private Life series of books traces a clear line from how society moved from an entirely-public to an almost entirely-private way of life. Along the way, it also shows how people's perceptions of themselves, their homes, their families, and their possessions changed, and how their ways of celebrating life events changed. Of course, within the confines of those examinations are hundreds of pages of details about everyday life in Italy during the Renaissance.

Though I'm not a real fan of Duby's writing (it can be a little dry, which isn't surprising given that it's just about all translated from French), he's not writing most of this book--just editing for the most part--so you need have no fears that it's not readable. This book is an absolute treasure-trove of information for researchers.

Among the chapters in this book:

  • Introduction: Private Power, Public Power. Definitions from Latin and other languages of the very words "public" and "private".

  • Portraits: Aristocratic Households of Feudal France. Ecclesiastical life, visions of heaven and hell, how people interacted with the buildings they'd created, power structures within the family and church and rulers, customs of hospitality and how strangers/visitors/travelers were treated, and more. Plenty of info about daily life in monasteries and nunneries, and how families lived. Info about servants, serfs, wedding customs, how kids were treated and how they were educated and raised, and so much more.

  • Tuscan Notables on the Eve of the Renaissance. This is the part most people will like a lot. Just about everything you could ever want is in here. No citations, which is irritating, but you'll find here a clear line drawn from the previous attitudes toward public and private life, and how that evolved into the pageantry and pomp and outward show that was a Florentine's life. Births, weddings, family structure, men and women and how they related, what happened when they died, how literature treated subjects like homosexuality and adultery, how the Church twined itself into just about every aspect of daily life, and how servants and slaves were treated. Really, name a subject and it's in here somewhere, at least in passing.

  • There are plenty of photos of architecture and artwork too, which is sure to please; the buildings are particularly impressive, especially the various stark-faced palaces of the obscenely wealthy. And, too, the literature quoted here is perfectly illustrative. All of this chapter serves to create a step toward how people began to see themselves as private entities with boundaries clearly drawn between themselves and the outer world.

  • Imagining the Self. Now we move toward a world where language shapes, and is shaped by, new ways of seeing one's relationship with the Divine and the outside world. The veiled language of allegory (such as "garden" meaning a place that is private but ideal for meetings), how-to books and their advice of how to safeguard privacy and how to courteously provide privacy to others, and narrative arts and how they show us the new ways of seeing enclosed worlds like nunneries and private homes.

  • Civilizing the Fortress: 11th to 13th Century. The protective functions of castles in this time period, and their general outlay and architecture. Examinations of their main parts, such as a large section devoted to how people interacted with the main hall, and how these became more livable and less single-mindedly protective as time went on.

  • Peasant Hearth to Papal Palace: The 14th and 15th Centuries. Taxation, the meanings of the word "hearth" and how it applied specifically to the family unit and home. Composition of Italian households and the kind of houses they had; how tax records show us what the houses were like and what sort of rooms they had in them. The kind of food that was eaten and how meals were taken. Farms, parks, estate enclosures, convents and their very enclosed lands, and diagrams of house plans from the era. Even dimensions of hallways and corridors are included. Convenience features like private wells, and how the family thought of their houses. From there we move to the really big houses, like papal palaces, with the same sort of information: where people lived, what rooms were called and how they specialized, and diagrams of house plans. Furniture, too.

  • Solitude: 11th to 13th Century. How people in such crowded cities managed to find personal space. How individualization is shown by the various religious sculptures of the time, and in the biographies that were written then. The Carthusian heresy and how it related to a greater view of privacy. Literature of knights-errant and courtly love and its role in displaying and promoting the idea of private life and obedience. Enforced silence and obedience being a sign of withdrawal from the public eye. How the physical body's depictions in art and literature goes from a concept of being dangerous to one of being pleasurable.

  • Toward Intimacy: The 14th and 15th Centuries.The invention of subjectivity. Family memoirs (particularly by Giovanni Morelli and Donato Velluti) and how they are kept private and also seen as a form of civic duty, but also a display of a narcissism hitherto unseen. Signs and codes to delineate one group from another--keeping a 'club' private from society's main eye. How bodily functions came to be seen as improper for public viewing. Bathing and how it came to be seen as essential. Religious exaltation seen as one way spirituality was kept separate from secular life.

  • Of course, there's an extensive index and bibliography; the index leaves out a bit, but overall it's useful. The bibliography also includes photo credits in case you want to go hunt down one or more of the visual aids in the book. As you can imagine this book is absolutely huge, over 600 pages! And just about all of it's useful to research. Don't miss this one. Thankfully, it's not expensive at all; I got mine for less than $10 used.



    Back to Reviews Home

    All text copyright Vangelista di Antonio Dellaluna, except where otherwise noted. You may use anything you find here for any nonprofit purpose, but please give credit where credit is due.